Newsflash:
Elizabeth Warren Stop Global Warming Death by a Thousand Cuts: Illinois Coal Tragedies Continue
Friday, 16 May 2014 01:34

Death by a Thousand Cuts: Illinois Coal Tragedies Continue

Written by  Jeff Biggers | Huffington Post
Death by a Thousand Cuts: Illinois Coal Tragedies Continue Credit Peabody Energy

With the death toll still mounting at a coal mine in Turkey, another southern Illinois coal miner lost his life this week, along with two West Virginia miners. The state of Illinois, meanwhile -- called out at public hearings for a brewing coal ash catastrophe -- handed out a controversial National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit for a Peabody Energy strip mine in southern Illinois, placing the community of Rocky Branch one step closer to destruction.

Bottom line: Death by a thousand cuts policy in Illinois coal country.

And all the more reason for the growing sense of urgency in southern Illinois for acoalfields regeneration plan to transition to clean energy jobs.

"The death of individual miners is indeed tragic and unnecessary," said Sam Stearns, a former coal miner in Saline County, and long-time Shawnee Forest activist. "Also unnecessary are the thousands of deaths each year which are attributable to burning coal, as well as the displacement of entire communities for the sake of a few short-term jobs. This will be a focus of the Heartwood Forest Council in Ozark, Illinois, on Memorial Day Weekend. We have a unique program of experts ready to discuss how to stop mining deaths and how to keep communities alive through a just transition to sustainable energy jobs."

Last year, the Illinois Department of Natural Resources was singled out in an audit for its lack of mine inspectors, as required by state law.

This week's miner's death was the second fatality in the last seven months at the Sugar Camp MC I mine in southern Illinois. The SNL news reported today:

According to MSHA's Pattern of Violations Monthly Monitoring Tool, the mine met two of the four elements under one set of criteria for pattern violator status. The mine recorded 171 significant and substantial violations in the most recent 12-month period, over three times the criteria threshold of 50, and reported an injury severity measure of 2,197.8 -- more than five times the criteria's five-year average of mines of similar type and classification.

The abuse of the miner always goes hand-in-hand with the abuse of the land, as folks in southern Illinois know too well.

Case in point: While Gov. Pat Quinn hailed the state's clean water initiatives, the Illinois EPA released its "Responsiveness Summary" yesterday, as part of the approval of the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit for the Rocky Branch strip mine. The "Summary" includes standard bureaucratic replies to still unanswered community concerns about inevitable mining pollution and contamination of the Rocky Branch watershed and area waterways, as well as flooding and other unresolved problems.

Here are some typically cringe-worthy I-EPA replies: For question #16, on the cumulative impact of nearby mines, the I-EPA responded:

In the instance of the proposed mine, the nearest downstream water body that has been assessed by the Agency is Segment AT-05 of the Saline River. The existing water quality of this river contains the cumulative impacts of pollution from Will Scarlet mine and other NPDES dischargers in the upstream watershed.The pollutants typically associated with mining in Illinois (chloride, iron, manganese, and sulfate) have not been found to be contributing to impairment of this stream segment.

When asked in question #19, "why doesn't the Illinois EPA list the detriments of the proposed mining to the community in this section," the I-EPA essentially cut and paste from Peabody Energy public relations material:

This continue mining operation in Saline County would bring in tens of millions of dollars to the area by increasing the wealth of the region, generating additional value to manufacturing companies, generating additional revenue to wholesale trade companies, increasing the value of the health care sector, regional finance and insurance companies.


Health care sector? As in black lung disease, accidents and water contamination, perhaps.

In fact, the I-EPA admits at one point that it has failed to do any actual fact-finding research and relies primarily on Peabody data: For question #21:

21. Does IEPA fact check the analysis of the alternative treatment technologies listed here or are these answers just provided by Peabody mining?

The alternative treatment technologies summarized in the Antidegradation Assessment for this proposed permit were provided by Peabody. The onus of researching and assessing alternatives is on the Applicant, as this information is required in the permit application for any proposed increase in pollutant loading that necessitates a new, renewed, or modified NPDES permit. As required by 35 I ll. Adm. Code 302.105(c)(2)(C), the Agency uses all information, data, or reports from the Applicant as well as its own sources, and also relies on Agency experience with factually similar permitting scenarios. The Agency may "fact check" the alternatives information provided by the Applicant. In this case, this was not needed given the familiarity and working knowledge of Agency technical staff with projects of this nature.

One last nugget: Despite the fact that four out of the five members of the I-EPA public hearing committee publicly admitted in February, at the NPDES hearing in Harrisburg, that they had NOT bothered to visit the proposed mining area, the "Summary" blatantly contradicts their testimonies and states: "It is noted that a site reconnaissance visit was performed prior to the public hearing in order for the hearing panel members to become familiar with the local area, topography and relative location of proposed facilities and mining areas."

What's true, what's false? The confusion is part of the death by a thousand cuts policy.

Here are some more facts -- and cuts: According to the Illinois DNR website, "the Coal Mining Act stipulates that state mine inspectors must conduct inspections at least once a month at every coal mine in the state." However, a 2011 survey by the Prairie Rivers organization, assessing data from EPA's Enforcement and Compliance History Online (ECHO) based on reports ("discharge monitoring reports") submitted by the mine personnel, came to these conclusions:

Of the 72 coal mines operating with water pollution discharge/effluent (or NPDES) permits in Illinois, 

- Only 12 have had inspections conducted by the Illinois EPA in the last five years.

- Over 35 have self-reported non compliance with their permits.

- In the last three years, 34 of these facilities (47%) have been out of compliance with their permit for 2 quarters (6 months) or more.

- In the last three years, 21 of these facilities (29%) have been out of compliance with their permit for 4 quarters (12 months) or more.

- In the last three years, 9 of these facilities (13%)have been out of compliance with their permit for 8 quarters (24 months) or more.

- In the last three years, 4 of these facilities (6%) have been out of compliance with their permit for 12 quarters - that means out of compliance for every month of the last three years.

- In the last three years, 12 of these facilities (17%) have had > 10 effluent exceedances.

- In the last three years, 3 of these facilities (4%) have had > 50 effluent exceedances.

- 17 of the 35 mines (49%) not in compliance had more than half of their effluents exceedances greater than 50% of the permitted limit

(i.e. Permit limit for total suspended solids = 70 mg/L, effluent violation ≥ 105 mg/L)

- 15 of the 35 mines (43%) not in compliance had more than half of their effluent exceedances greater than 100% of the permitted limit

(i.e. Permit limit for total suspended solids = 70 mg/L, effluent violation ≥ 140 mg/L)

- 15 of the 35 mines (43%) not in compliance had instances of permit violations in exceedances of 1000% of their permitted limit

(i.e. Permit limit for total suspended solids = 70 mg/L, effluent violation ≥ 700 mg/L)

- 14 of the 35 mines (40%) not in compliance had instances of permit violations in exceedances of 19900% of their permitted limit

(i.e. Permit limit for total suspended solids = 70 mg/L, effluent violation ≥ 13,930 mg/L)

- 8 of the 35 mines (23%) not in compliance had instances of permit violations in exceedances of 29900% of their permitted limit

(i.e. Permit limit for total suspended solids = 70 mg/L, effluent violation ≥ 20,930 mg/L)

- 6 of the 35 mines (17%) not in compliance had instances of permit violations in exceedances of 39900% of their permitted limit

(i.e. Permit limit for total suspended solids = 70 mg/L, effluent violation ≥ 27,930 mg/L)

- 2 of the 35 mines not in compliance had instances of permit violations in exceedances of 59900% of their permitted limit

(i.e. Permit limit for total suspended solids = 70 mg/L, effluent violation ≥ 41,930 mg/L)

- Another 25 have been in violation with their permit for not reporting whether their pollution discharges were in compliance with their permits. So, the Agency and the public do not know how these sites are operating.

- Only 12 have both submitted their reports AND shown they were in compliance with their pollution limits.

- Informal enforcement actions have been issued at 12 of the mine sites. Example of this is a letter to the permittee called a "Notice of Violation".

- No formal enforcement actions have been undertaken at any of the sites.

- No penalties for noncompliance have been assessed.

- Nineteen of these mines discharge pollution into streams that are already considered "impaired" by the Illinois EPA. That means that the streams are not clean enough to support their designated uses of either drinking water, support for aquatic life, or recreation. Of these, IEPA has evaluated that 17 of the coal mine operations may be a potential contributor to the cause of impairment.

Original article on Huffington Post

Read 6269 times

ERA Legislation in your State

Unratified states Gold - Ratified States Purple

Latest News from the Warren Campaign

  • Will new senators push Democrats to the left?
    Will new senators push Democrats to the left?

    When Massachusetts Democrat Elizabeth Warren and the rest of the 2013 class of liberal senators start work this month, they'll have to do more than figure out the byzantine ways of getting things done in Washington.

    They'll also have to decide how seriously to engage a progressive movement that sees their assent a historic opportunity to shift the Democratic Party to the left.

    Written on Saturday, 05 January 2013 19:11 Read more...
  • Elizabeth Warren Wins Senate Banking Committee Seat: Sources
    Elizabeth Warren Wins Senate Banking Committee Seat: Sources

    WASHINGTON -- Nearly two years after Wall Street waged a successful campaign to keep consumer advocate Elizabeth Warren from running the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the incoming senator will be tapped to serve on the Banking Committee, according to four sources familiar with the situation. 

    Written on Tuesday, 04 December 2012 19:22 Read more...
  • Elizabeth Warren Redefines "Balanced Approach"
    Elizabeth Warren Redefines "Balanced Approach"

    Politico recently declared, "The Senate is about to become a liberal lion’s den." 

    In 2012, groups like the Progressive Change Campaign Committee, MoveOn.org, CREDO Action, and Democracy for America worked hard to build progressive power in Congress. This week's iconic photo of Senators-elect Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Tammy Baldwin (D-WI) walking together down the corridors of power is symbolic of the rising progressive tide. 

    Written on Sunday, 18 November 2012 14:20 Read more...
  • Elizabeth Warren Wins the "Which Side Are You On?" Debate
    Elizabeth Warren Wins the "Which Side Are You On?" Debate

    An overbearing and at times ridiculously aggressive Massachusetts Senator Scott Brown came across as a desperate man Thursday night, as he attempted to gain the upper hand in the first debateof this year's most closely-watched U.S. Senate race and, by extension, in a reelection contest that seems to be slipping away from him.

    Written on Sunday, 23 September 2012 16:27 Read more...
  • Mayor Menino to endorse Elizabeth Warren in Senate race at Roslindale Square rally on Friday
    Mayor Menino to endorse Elizabeth Warren in Senate race at Roslindale Square rally on Friday

    Mayor Thomas M. Menino is expected to endorse Democrat Elizabeth Warren on Friday in her bid to unseat Republican US Senator Scott Brown, according to two people with knowledge of the plan.

    Written on Thursday, 20 September 2012 19:47 Read more...
  • Elizabeth Warren's DNC Speech: "Corporations Are Not People"
    Elizabeth Warren's DNC Speech: "Corporations Are Not People"

    Bill Clinton may have stolen the show at the DNC last night with his 45-minute, half-ad-libbed barn-burner of a speech, but there were a few other noteworthy speakers as well. After dragging for an hour or two, the night's program picked up when Massachusetts Senate candidate, CFPB creator, and economic realtalker extraordinaire Elizabeth Warren took the stage.

    Written on Thursday, 06 September 2012 18:54 Read more...
  • Elizabeth Warren: Yes She Can?
    Elizabeth Warren: Yes She Can?

    It was a grim, sleety day in Chicopee, a gritty postindustrial town in western Massachusetts, where paint flakes off worn-out bridges and boarded-up factories. At a community relations luncheon, kind security guards were opening back doors and holding out umbrellas for the few willing to brave the freezing slush.

    Written on Wednesday, 16 May 2012 04:54 Read more...
  • Jonathan Klate: A candidate's connection
    Jonathan Klate: A candidate's connection

    Retired Amherst gentleman John Kick is not known as a political activist. In the Springfield union hall where he ventured last October to hear Democratic senatorial candidate Elizabeth Warren, he might have seemed a world-weary citizen with vague curiosity about the professor turned politician.

    But John's sorrowful demeanor and disconsolate eyes betrayed a woefully wounded heart. His son, Gabe, took his own life just a month earlier, at the age of 28. John keeps moving, somehow, in the dreadful private agony understood only by parents who persist in such an aftermath.

    Written on Monday, 26 March 2012 17:09 Read more...
  • The Ascendance of Elizabeth Warren
    The Ascendance of Elizabeth Warren

    If you’re reading this, you probably already know how you feel about Elizabeth Warren. Warren is currently running for Senate in Massachusetts, in the hopes of knocking out Republican incumbent Scott Brown. Very few first-time candidates are so well-known, or so passionately beloved.

    Written on Monday, 26 March 2012 00:00 Read more...
  • NOW PAC Endorses Elizabeth Warren
    NOW PAC Endorses Elizabeth Warren

    NOW/PAC is thrilled to announce its endorsement of Democratic candidate Elizabeth Warren for the U. S. Senate from the state of Massachusetts. Warren is the most prominent of the three Democrats vying to run against incumbent Sen. Scott Brown (R) in the general election. Recent polls show Warren neck and neck with Brown.

    Written on Monday, 05 March 2012 19:48 Read more...
  • Elizabeth Warren Says Washington Must Act Now To Help Stem The Tide Of Foreclosure
    Elizabeth Warren Says Washington Must Act Now To Help Stem The Tide Of Foreclosure

    Backs MA Congressmen, Attorney General Coakley Calling on Federal Housing Finance Agency to Take Action To Prevent Unnecessary Foreclosures

    BOSTON – It is past time for the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) to step up and help prevent unnecessary foreclosures in Massachusetts, said Consumer Advocate Elizabeth Warren, reinforcing calls from members of the Massachusetts Congressional delegation and Attorney General Martha Coakley.

    Written on Wednesday, 22 February 2012 07:54 Read more...
  • U.S. Rep. Jim McGovern this week endorsed Democratic candidate Elizabeth Warren for the United States Senate.

    U.S. Rep. Jim McGovern this week endorsed Democratic candidate Elizabeth Warren for the United States Senate.

    Written on Friday, 27 January 2012 20:35 Read more...
  • The Woman Who Knew Too Much
    The Woman Who Knew Too Much

    Millions of Americans hoped President Obama would nominate Elizabeth Warren to head the consumer financial watchdog agency she had created. Instead, she was pushed aside. As Warren kicks off her run for Scott Brown’s Senate seat in Massachusetts, Suzanna Andrews charts the Harvard professor’s emergence as a champion of the beleaguered middle class, and her fight against a powerful alliance of bankers, lobbyists, and politicians.

    Written on Wednesday, 16 November 2011 00:00 Read more...
  • Elizabeth Warren's Appeal
    Elizabeth Warren's Appeal

    For a few years now, politicians straining against all of the antigovernment demagogy have been searching for a way to energize public interest and remind voters of the essential government services and protections they rely on and all too often take for granted.

    Written on Sunday, 16 October 2011 00:00 Read more...
  • Berkshire Democrats Want Elizabeth to Run, Run, Run
    Berkshire Democrats Want Elizabeth to Run, Run, Run

    PITTSFIELD, Mass. —  More than a few local Democrats would be ecstatic if Elizabeth Warren decides to run against Scott Brown for the U.S. Senate. Warren is kicking around the idea of running and stopped in Pittsfield on Friday to meet with party members to gauge their support as part of a listening tour across the state.

    Written on Friday, 19 August 2011 00:00 Read more...

Sign the ERA Petition

ERADemandButton

On Friday, September 12th more than 150 activists will go to DC and Demand that their Senators and Representatives support removing the ratification deadline from the ERA (SJ Res 15 and HJ Res 113)

Button-SignERAPetition

Sign the Petition - Sen. Sanders Run as a Democrat in 2016

Button-SandersPetition

Like Elizabeth Warren

Lori Wallach on the TPP from PDA Progressive Roundtable

Progressive Roundtable with Reps. Ellison and Pocan and Lori Wallach on TPP

TPP: The Biggest Threat to the Internet You've Probably Never Heard Of