Wednesday, 11 February 2015 00:00

Public employee unions under fire again

Written by  Brian Mahony | Politico
Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner. | Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner. | AP Photo

Public-sector workers are under fire again — and not just from Republicans.

Three years after Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker curtailed collective bargaining and New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie cut pension benefits for public employees in the name of budget austerity, state and local politicians once again are moving to curtail public-sector unions.

The most aggressive moves are coming from Illinois’ newly inaugurated Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner. On Monday, Rauner issued an executive order prohibiting unions from collecting so-called fair share fees from non-union members. These mandatory fees come from government workers who choose not to be union members but are nonetheless represented by unions in contract negotiations. In effect, Rauner’s order by fiat makes Illinois a right-to-work state for public employees — a measure that, opponents argue, requires legislation.

But some Democrats have lately put public-employee unions in the hot seat too. For Democrats, the target is typically teachers unions, whose frequent opposition to education reforms has proved infuriating to big-city mayors.

Democratic New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo has spoken of removing “ineffective teachers” and expanding charter schools, prompting the New York State United Teachers to launch a media campaign to “fight back” against the governor’s agenda. “Education is our life. For this you have made us the enemy. This is personal,” a group of teachers said in an open letter to Cuomo printed Monday in the Times Union of Albany.

The Chicago Teachers Union has lofted similar rhetoric against Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, a Democrat. CTU President Karen Lewis even considered challenging Emanuel in the current mayoral election, though eventually she dropped out, citing health reasons.

Emanuel and Rauner, it happens, are friends and former business associates from Emanuel’s time at the investment firm Wasserstein Perella in the late 1990s. Although Emanuel endorsed Rauner’s opponent, incumbent Gov. Pat Quinn, in November’s election, and though the two disagree on many issues, Emanuel and Rauner are, one Democratic strategist told the Chicago Tribune in August, “cut from the same cloth.” One point of agreement is a keen frustration with the CTU.

In addition to differences over education reform, Democratic politicians have sometimes clashed with public-employee unions over pensions that are squeezing state budgets. Here, too, Illinois features prominently, because nowhere does the state pension problem weigh more heavily. The state’s Democratic attorney general, Lisa Madigan, is arguing in court for emergency powers to trim state pension benefits.

“As expenditures on benefits increase,” writes Daniel DiSalvo, senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a conservative nonprofit, in his 2015 book “Public Union Power and Its Consequences,” these expenditures “‘crowd out’ government spending on parks, education, public safety and other services on which the poor and middle class rely. In short, government costs more but does less.” Such pressures are felt by Republicans and Democrats alike — indeed, so much so that some Democrats now openly pronounce themselves anti-union. In his book, DiSalvo quotes San Jose Mayor Chuck Reed, a Democrat who’s clashed with public-employee unions, saying, “There’s a difference between being liberal and progressive and being a union Democrat.”

Mostly, though, recent challenges to public employees have come from Republicans. Walker, who halted fair share fees in Wisconsin through legislation, thus far has resisted pressure from Republican legislators to extend right-to-work to private employees. But in defending his proposed $300 million in cuts to the University of Wisconsin, Walker recently suggested that the faculty “start thinking about teaching more classes and doing more work.” Newly elected GOP Wisconsin state Treasurer Matt Adamczyk, not to be outdone, fired his entire staff after assuming office and has pledged to shut the office down entirely.

Right-to-work bills introduced in New Mexico, Missouri and West Virginia would prohibit public and/or private unions from collecting mandatory dues or their equivalent in workplaces that they’ve organized. The bills have already cleared committee hurdles in New Mexico and Missouri. All but the Missouri bill were introduced by Republicans; in Missouri, the measure was introduced by state Rep. Courtney Curtis, a Democrat and an African-American who would limit right to work to the construction industry to combat what he sees as bias in minority contracting. In Kentucky, right-to-work ordinances have been passed in five counties, though it isn’t clear federal law allows the adoption of right to work anywhere except at the state and territorial level. Legal challenges are already underway.

Renewed strafing of the public-sector workforce is primarily the result of November’s Republican sweep, in which the GOP seized the governorships of Massachusetts, Maryland, Arkansas and Illinois, all previously Democratic, while losing only Pennsylvania, for a net gain of two. (Alaska’s newly elected governor is independent Bill Walker, who ousted Republican Sean Parnell.) The GOP also acquired control of 11 previously Democratic legislative chambers, including the West Virginia House, the New York Senate and the Nevada Assembly and Senate. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, Republicans haven’t controlled this many state legislative seats since 1920.

The GOP has a clear political incentive to curb public-union power. Public-sector workers have a rate of union membership of 35.7 percent, five times higher than that of the private workforce. And unions like the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees are big donors to Democrats. AFSCME spent $32 million on political activities and lobbying in 2013, the most recent year for which data are available.

For decades, public-sector unions grew even as private-sector union membership shrank to less than 7 percent of the national workforce. But over the past decade, AFSCME’s membership remained essentially flat, according to the Center for Union Facts, an anti-union group that collects statistics on labor organizations. Today membership is about 1.4 million.

Rauner (whom CTU’s Lewis recently called “Scott Walker on steroids”) has emerged lately as the most aggressive adversary to public-sector unions. At the same time Rauner signed his executive order against fair share fees, he filed a federal lawsuit in Chicago asking a court to approve his order. “Forced union dues are a critical cog in the corrupt bargain that is crushing taxpayers,” Rauner said. “An employee who is forced to pay unfair share dues is being forced to fund political activity with which they disagree. That is a clear violation of First Amendment rights — and something that, as governor, I am duty bound to correct.”

“It is crystal clear by this action,” answered Roberta Lynch, executive director of AFSCME Local 31, “that the governor’s supposed concern for balancing the state budget is a paper-thin excuse that can’t hide his real agenda: silencing working people and their unions who stand up for the middle class.” Local 31 represents about 35,000 state employees, the majority of whom are members, the union said.

It’s possible the executive order is intended less as a policy shift than as a bargaining chip. Rauner’s executive order comes five months before Local 31’s contract with the state is due to expire. The union has not entered into serious negotiations on the contract and has made only made preliminary contacts with Rauner’s staff.

But it’s also possible Rauner aims to deal a knockout blow to the mandatory collection of public-employee union dues or their equivalent nationwide.

Rauner’s lawsuit cites a U.S. Supreme Court opinion issued last summer, Harris v. Quinn, which prevented public unions from collecting fees from a small group of private-sector workers under contract with state governments. The court could have gone further to declare mandatory public-sector union fees unconstitutional, but it chose not to. Rauner’s suit appears designed to compel the Supreme Court to take a second look, and the court may be willing. And it may soon take up another case challenging mandatory teacher-union fees in California.

Public-employee unions can mostly be expected to campaign against next year’s GOP primary field, and especially against Walker and Christie. One possible exception is the conservative International Association of Fire Fighters, whose president, Harold Schaitberger, met with Jeb Bush last month. Schaitberger said his 300,000-strong union is about 44 percent Republican. While Schaitberger had few nice things to say about Christie, who forced cuts to firefighter pensions in New Jersey, he had warm words for Bush.

“Even though Jeb was trying to trim down government in Florida — he reduced overall government employment,” Schaitberger told POLITICO, he “was friendly to firefighters.”

Link to original article from Politico
Read 1145 times

Latest End Corporate Rule News

  • Danny Schechter Was Our News Dissector

    It is impossible to fully explain media criticism—and media understanding—as it exists today without recognizing the remarkable contribution of Danny Schechter. Two years before Ben Bagdikian took apart the fantasy that American media was liberal, withThe Elite Conspiracy and Other Crimes by the Press (Harper & Row), more than a decade before Bagdikian exposed

    Read More
  • AFJ urges CFPB to prohibit forced arbitration in consumer financial products

    WASHINGTON, D.C., MARCH 10, 2015: Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron released this statement today in response to the release of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s report on forced arbitration: We commend the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau for its conducting the comprehensive, in-depth study of forced arbitration released today, and

    Read More
  • AFJ urges CFPB to prohibit forced arbitration in consumer financial products

    Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron released this statement today in response to the release of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s report on forced arbitration:

    Read More
  • The Pope v. Citizens United

    Campaign finance reformers have been on a steady losing streak in the courts and Congress. But they may finally have found a champion who can elevate their cause: Pope Francis. "We must achieve a free sort of election campaign, not financed," the Pope told an Argentine magazine in an interview released this

    Read More
  • The Real Cost of 'Amazon Sunday'

    Mail carriers are at the mercy of a brutal postal management looking to appease Amazon. With the enactment of what many postal employees have come to call “AmazonSunday,” a program offering Sunday package delivery for Amazon’s Prime customers, the United States Postal Service management began the compulsory seven-day workweek for its

    Read More
  • As FCC Releases Net Neutrality Rules, Battle Lines Form

    Supporters of internet freedom must now defend sweeping reforms from industry attacks, say advocates Two weeks after the Federal Communications Commission passed a historic set of rules to protect the open internet, opponents of net neutrality have begun scrutinizing the full text of the rules, released Thursday, in likely anticipation of legal

    Read More
  • Historic Win for Internet as FCC announces strong new rules to save Net Neutrality after over 5 million Internet users spoke out

    February 26, 2015 – The Federal Communications Commission has just announced strong new Net Neutrality rules. Experts say the new rules will entrench net neutrality and prevent telecom conglomerates from creating ‘slow lanes’ on the Internet.

    Read More
  • A “Grand Alliance” To Save Our Public Postal Service

    The Conservative/Wall Street/1 Percent/Republican anti-government strategy is to set government up to fail (usually by starving it of funding). Then they point to the resulting “crisis” they created and say it proves that government doesn’t work so we should “privatize” it – in other words, rig the system against We the

    Read More
  • 81-Year-Old Completes 400-Mile Trek for Campaign Finance Reform

    Rhanna Bazzini's march to Florida Capitol honors legacy of activist Granny D. Honoring the legacy of the late campaign finance reform crusader known as Granny D, 81-year-old Rhana Bazzini on Wednesday completed an over 400-mile trek from Sarasota to the Florida Capitol in Tallahassee in a crusade calling for a

    Read More
  • Black Lives Depend on a Free and Open Internet

    Black Lives Matter was born as a social media response to this verdict, meant to interrupt a public narrative that criminalizes and devalues Black people’s lives in America. With support from techies, designers, artists and thousands of activists across the country, Black Lives Matter is now an online to offline

    Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6

Featured News

  • Progressive Caucus on Leaked ISDS Provisions in the Trans-Pacific Partnership +

    WASHINGTON – Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC) Co-Chairs Reps. Raúl M. Grijalva (D-AZ) and Keith Ellison (D-MN) released the following statement after Read More
  • Obama Promises Rare Veto As House Votes to Slow Down Union Elections, Curb NLRB +

    In a show of electoral strength by anti-union Republicans in Congress, the U.S. House of Representatives easily passed legislation Thursday Read More
  • GOP Budget Slashes Tax Rates for the 1 Percent, Safety Net for Everyone Else +

    Proposal, columnist writes, 'is based on an economic philosophy that has failed the country and its people savagely in the Read More
  • TPP Media March +

    Join our TPP Twitter Storm. Everyone with a Twitter account can participate. The Twitter storm begins on Tuesday at 9pm Read More
  • The People's Budget: Progressive Proposal Aims to Un-Rig Failed Economic System +

    The budget plan 'fixes an economy that, for too long, has failed to provide the opportunities American families need to Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • 21
  • 22
  • 23
  • 24
  • 25
  • 26
  • 27
  • 28
  • 29
  • 30
  • 31
  • 32
  • 33
  • 34
  • 35
  • 36
  • 37

Does Your Legislator Support the ERA



Featured End Corporate Rule News

  • Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. +, the giant online retailer, has too much power, and it uses that power in ways that hurt America. O.K., Read More
  • End Corporate Rule +

    Time and again, whether we are seeking sensible healthcare, environmental, economic, or foreign policy—supported by a majority of Americans—we hit Read More
  • A Short History of Postal Banking +

    As the debate over reinstituting postal banking heats up, we should know we had it. And it worked. Last week Read More
  • A New Postal Union Leader Really Doesn't Want Mail Sent From Staples +

    It’s unusual for a challenger to unseat an incumbent president in the postal workers’ union election, but Mark Dimondstein did Read More
  • Local GMO Fights Smash Records as Monsanto's Millions Bankroll Opposition +

    Citizen-led initiatives to regulate GMOs in Hawaii, Oregon and Colorado face deep pockets of outside industry groups Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

End Corporate Rule Calls

  • Listen to this month's call with special guests Mark Dudzik and Katherine Isaac, as they share their insider knowledge and...
  • This month's call is all about determining our action for 2015. The status of constitutional amendments is discussed, as...
  • Listen to this month's call as the team recaps the actions around the 5th anniversary of the Citizens United decision. A...