Newsflash:
Rep. Barbara Lee Elizabeth Warren Will new senators push Democrats to the left?
Saturday, 05 January 2013 19:11

Will new senators push Democrats to the left?

Written by  Brian Montopoli | CBSNews
Elizabeth Warren Elizabeth Warren

When Massachusetts Democrat Elizabeth Warren and the rest of the 2013 class of liberal senators start work this month, they'll have to do more than figure out the byzantine ways of getting things done in Washington.

They'll also have to decide how seriously to engage a progressive movement that sees their assent a historic opportunity to shift the Democratic Party to the left.

"The cavalry is arriving," said Adam Green, cofounder of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee. "A lot of news coverage after the election focused on Democrats winning two seats, but the big story for us is the composition of the Democratic caucus has moved in a massively progressive direction."

Warren, the consumer advocate who articulates a full-throated populism rarely heard in Washington in recent years, is the most prominent of the new progressive members. But she is far from alone: There's Wisconsin's Tammy Baldwin, who hails from the liberal bastion of Madison; Connecticut's Chris Murphy, a loyal Democrat who replaces the moderate Joe Lieberman; and Hawaii's Mazie Hirono, who during her tenure in the House has been a leading member of the Congressional Progressive Caucus. They are the sort of Democrats who don't mind discussing a strong role for government in American life.

The four incoming senators join progressives Sherrod Brown of Ohio and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island - both of whom were reelected in November - and other liberal stalwarts in the Senate, among them Bernie Sanders of Vermont, Jeff Merkley of Oregon and Al Franken of Minnesota. Meanwhile, moderates Democrats Ben Nelson of Nebraska, Kent Conrad of North Dakota and Lieberman of Connecticut (an independent who caucuses with Democrats) - all of whom have repeatedly angered progressives - have retired.

The new crop of left-leaning senators and their progressive allies reflect something of a break with the modern Democratic Party. In the 1990s, then-president Bill Clinton and the Democratic Leadership Council successfully moved the party away from the economic populism and leftist positions it had embraced since the late 1960s. It was a vision reflected by Mr. Clinton's decision in 1996 to sign legislation to end "welfare as we know it," and his declaration that the "era of big government is over." Liberals derided the "triangulation" reflected by Mr. Clinton's policies as reflecting an abdication of what the Democratic Party stands for.

Despite claims by some on the right that President Obama has a "socialist agenda" - in the words of Mr. Clinton's onetime aide, Dick Morris, who has been credited as the father of triangulation - progressives have lamented that Mr. Obama has largely not sought to return his party to the unapologetic populism of the pre-Clinton era. While they stood by Mr. Obama in the 2012 election cycle, they rallied enthusiastically around Warren, who did not shy away from deeming the economic and political system "rigged" against the middle class. The rhetoric of Warren and the other new Senate progressives has prompted comparisons to progressive heroes like Paul Wellstone and Hubert Humphrey - along with George McGovern, whose trouncing in the 1972 presidential election helped give rise to the Democratic Leadership Council.

Green says the influx of progressive voices in the Senate will "embolden everybody to advance more progressive priorities." And he argues that polling proves that progressive positions, such as protecting entitlement programs, are embraced by most Americans and thus deserving of unapologetic Democratic support. "There's no reason that any Democrat in the caucus should ever get behind cuts to any of these benefits if they care about what's political popular," he said.

Others are more skeptical.

"I don't expect [the Senate] to change much if at all," said Jim Manley, a former top communications aide to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and "liberal lion" Sen. Edward M. Kennedy. "I appreciate the idea that there's an influx of progressives, and I think that's good news, but the fact is until you get 60 votes to cut off a filibuster, you're going to need to compromise to get anything done, and Senator Reid is going to continue to look out for the caucus as a whole. For every Elizabeth Warren, there's a Mark Pryor who's up for reelection in 2014."

Pryor hails from the largely red state of Arkansas, and is seen as among the most vulnerable Democrats facing reelection two years from now. Other Democrats in a similar position include Sens. Mark Begich of Alaska, Mary Landrieu of Louisiana, Max Baucus of Montana, Tim Johnson of South Dakota and Kay Hagan of North Carolina. If all six lose their seats and Democrats don't pick up any seats to offset the losses, the Democratic Party will go from a 55-vote majority in the Senate to a minority. It's also worth noting that some of the incoming senators who will caucus with Democrats - including Joe Donnelly of Indiana, Tim Kaine of Virginia and Angus King of Maine - will likely seek to push the party in a more moderate direction.

Manley argued that even if Reid wants to embrace a more progressive position, he's not going to risk losing the Senate to do so - especially since Republicans control the House and can block any progressive legislation. His recommendation to Warren and her progressive colleagues is to "do what Hillary Clinton did and what Sen. Barack Obama did, which is to keep your head down, attend your hearings, study your briefing books and pick and choose your spots and try to take on an important issue."

"I don't mean that they shouldn't take on issues and try and push them forward, but they've got to realize that in this hyper-partisan political atmosphere the chance for enacting such legislation is pretty slim," he added.

Congressional scholar Thomas Mann of the Brookings Institution agreed with Manley's take on the impact of the progressive newcomers, saying he is "skeptical of any significant change."

"The reason being our politics these days are very much shaped from the top down, rather than the bottom up," he said. "And nothing these people are bringing differ in any significant way from Sherrod Brown, from Sheldon Whitehouse and others."

Green, of the Progressive Campaign Change Committee, dismisses concerns about protecting vulnerable senators up for reelection as "old school, out of touch thinking," pointing to polls that show progressive positions popular in red states. Green acknowledged a cultural divide in some of these states, but said economic populism makes sense even for Democrats like Pryor. "Poor rural voters in Arkansas are not rooting for Wall Street to get away with murder, or to close on their houses," he said.

Even if Reid and the more moderate Democrats suppress efforts by progressive senators to push more liberal legislation, there are openings for progressives to assert themselves. Warren may be low on the totem pole in terms of seniority, but her assignment to the Senate Banking Committee will give her a perch from which to potentially make national headlines in her battles with Wall Street. And the ascension of Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., to the Budget Committee chairmanship, where she replaces Conrad, will mean a greater focus on liberal issues there. Conrad's focus was reducing the deficit; Murray says she will focus on "making sure we invest in the right places, in education, in job training, and to make sure we do a balanced approach moving forward." Progressive senators can also use leverage to move big pieces of legislation to the left, as they attempted to do in the "fiscal cliff" fight when they sent a letter to Mr. Obama demanding that he not buckle to Republican demands on revenues and spending cuts. 

All four of the incoming progressive senators declined to be interviewed for this article. That may be because discussing their plans is a no-win situation: If they say they are going to keep their heads down and play by the rules, as Manley advises, they risk angering progressives. If they say they plan to push hard for their agenda, seniority be damned, they risk angering their new colleagues in the tradition-obsessed Senate before their first day of work. A top aide to one of the incoming senators told CBS News that the structure of the Senate does not lend itself to dramatic legislative action; that won't change even if moderate filibuster reform goes into effect in the new Congress.

Some have speculated that the influx of progressive senators will mean further polarization of an already-polarized Congress, with the liberal Democratic wing occupying the same obstructionist position in the Senate that the tea party Republican wing plays in the House. Mann, author of "It's Even Worse Than It Looks: How the American Constitutional System Collided With the New Politics of Extremism," dismissed that concern.

"The Democratic Party has been repositioned as a center-left party, and that doesn't mean they don't articulate progressive goals and aspirations, but they're pragmatic people who know that to realize their ambitions substantively they've got to make the finances of the country whole," he said, arguing that the ideological extremism is "almost entirely" within the GOP. Even with the addition of the new progressive senators, he added, Democrats are "really a pragmatic lot, not an ideological lot."

The day after she won election, Warren vowed to reach across the aisle, saying she will "work with anyone" in order "to help get something done." Green argued that her focus should be not on moving toward Republicans but on harnessing progressive enthusiasm to force them - and her party - to move in her direction. He said one of her first priorities should be to push the Senate to reinstate the Glass-Steagall Act that mandated the separation of commercial and investment banking.

"We're living in a world where committee assignment and seniority takes a backseat to who can apply outside pressure in order to affect change from within," he said. "There's nobody in the Senate that's more capable of applying outside pressure for popular change than Elizabeth Warren."

"If the Senate passes popular Wall Street reform and the House blocks it, that just creates a valuable messaging opportunity for 2014," Green added. "And I'm sure Harry Reid would be happy about that."

Original article on CBSNews.com

Read 6473 times

ERA Legislation in your State

Unratified states Gold - Ratified States Purple

Latest News from the Lee Campaign

Latest News from the Grayson Campaign

Latest News from the Schapira Campaign

  • Standard-Bearer in Pivotal Arizona Congressional Race
    Standard-Bearer in Pivotal Arizona Congressional Race

    With early ballots in the mail, and only three weeks from the August 28th primary, State Senator David Schapira has emerged as the Democratic standard-bearer in a closely watched and increasingly nasty three-way congressional race in Arizona that many observers see as a litmus test for national Democratic chances to pick up critical seats in Congress.

    Written on Thursday, 09 August 2012 01:45 Read more...
  • Harry Mitchell Endorses David Schapira for Congress
    Harry Mitchell Endorses David Schapira for Congress

    “The primary in Congressional District 9 has pitted three of the brightest members of the Democratic Party in Arizona against each other. All three candidates are leaders in our state and I am honored to call them friends.

    Written on Thursday, 26 July 2012 12:14 Read more...
  • A Guest Post From Arizona Progressive State Senator David Schapira
    A Guest Post From Arizona Progressive State Senator David Schapira

    Endorsements are a funny thing. Most of them aren't worth anything at all. I have two friends running in the Democratic primary in Arizona's brand new 9th CD, Kyrsten Sinema and Andrei Cherny. Kyrsten is a progressive and Andrei is somewhere in his own world ideologically. But the third guy... well, he's the one who's been endorsed by Raúl-- and by PDA. Whomever wins the August 28th primary is, likelier than not, headed to Congress. That third guy is David Schapira, the Senate Democratic Leader.

    Written on Saturday, 30 June 2012 13:38 Read more...
  • David Schapira Receives PDA Endorsement
    David Schapira Receives PDA Endorsement

    On the May Inside the Party call, David Schapira (AZ-9) received the PDA National endorsement. Currently David Schapira is the Arizona State Senate Democratic Leader.

    Written on Thursday, 24 May 2012 00:00 Read more...
  • Arizona Communications Workers of America State Council Endorses David Schapira for Congress
    Arizona Communications Workers of America State Council Endorses David Schapira for Congress

    The Arizona Communications Workers of America (CWA) State Council announced today their endorsement of Senate Democratic Leader David Schapira, D-Tempe, in the race for Arizona’s Ninth Congressional District. The state council is comprised of the Arizona Correctional Peace Officers Association (AZCPOA), the Association of Flight Attendants-CWA and multiple CWA local affiliates.

    Written on Thursday, 17 May 2012 19:55 Read more...
  • Congressman Raúl Grijalva Endorses David Schapira
    Congressman Raúl Grijalva Endorses David Schapira

    Congressman Raúl Grijalva, AZ-07, today announced his endorsement of Arizona Senate Democratic Leader David Schapira, D-Tempe, in his campaign for Arizona’s Ninth Congressional District. “Voters are looking for candidates who stand up for what they believe in and can win, not by hiding their values, but by sharing them with voters. David is that candidate,” said Rep. Grijalva.

    Written on Monday, 30 April 2012 00:00 Read more...
  • Arizona Union Rights Stripped

    Arizona Governor Jan Brewer pushes the country's most anti-union agenda yet. David Shapira, Democratic leader of the Arizona state senate, slams his Republican colleagues. Welcome back to "The Ed Show." Jan Brewer and the Arizona Republicans are on a tear. they are on the offensive. they are on a mission to completely destroy public employee unions. have you heard the story before?

    Written on Thursday, 02 February 2012 00:00 Read more...
  • State Senator David Schapira Jumps Into District 9 Congressional Race
    State Senator David Schapira Jumps Into District 9 Congressional Race

    As predicted, former state Senator Kyrsten Sinema's not the only Democrat with her eye on Arizona's new Congressional seat -- this morning, state Senate Minority Leader David Schapira announced that he, too, will run in Arizona's newly formed 9th Congressional district.

    Written on Tuesday, 17 January 2012 00:00 Read more...

Sign the Petition - Sen. Sanders Run as a Democrat in 2016

Button-SandersPetition

Like Rep. Barbara Lee

Lori Wallach on the TPP from PDA Progressive Roundtable

Progressive Roundtable with Reps. Ellison and Pocan and Lori Wallach on TPP

TPP: The Biggest Threat to the Internet You've Probably Never Heard Of